Log in



The Movement of Monarchs

Wednesday, November 04, 2009 4:57 PM | Anonymous
Monarch_Cowpen_sm.jpg     The main mass of the Monarch migration missed us this year--and I promise to go lightly with the alliteration in the future, but it's hard to write about this amazing wildlife phenomenon without such accidents of grammar.  Where do these Monarchs end up?  In the mountains of Mexico.  I rest my case.

     Over the past weekend, Oct. 29-31, Greg Lasley reported that Monarchs were literally hard to miss as he drove Texas 87 from High Island to Bolivar Flats along the Upper Texas Coast.  Just in the past few days, on the TX-Butterfly discussion list, Harlen Aschen reported a huge movement of Monarchs near Port Lavaca.  These observations represent the last phase of the orchestrated Monarch march through Texas which began in August and September as the butterflies began making their way south of the Red River from all over the Midwest.

Monarch Fall Migration.jpg     The Monarch migration has captured the imagination of scientists and wildlife researchers for ages (see references, below).  Can you think of any other insect that has spawned such an enthusiastic suite of focal groups?  Perhaps the best known is Monarch Watch based out of the University of Kansas.  They have an active discussion list (Dplex-L) and a blog.  Also be sure to check out Journey North who, despite their name, follow Monarchs both north and south and also other migrating critters.  The Library of Congress has even set up a Science Reference Guide to offer students and researchers more information on Monarchs.  Several books have been written about this migration and it has been the subject of no small number of in-depth scientific symposia.







     In this year's Autumn movement, regional weather and wind patterns caused the major push of butterflies to circle around us to the west.  Compare the two maps below of the Fall migration for 2008 (left) and 2009 (right), downloaded and cropped from the Journey North maps page:

Fall 2008 Roosts_sm.gif              Fall 2009 Roosts_sm.gif
Sizeable Fall Monarch Roosts in 2008 (L) vs. 2009 (R).

To study these maps in detail, go to Journey North's website for Fall 2009 (or previous years), scroll down and click on the map for "Roosts" or "Peak sightings".  Be sure to click on the "Animated Map" link at the bottom of each map there to really get a feel for the flow of the migration.  Watch the pattern in 2009 as concentrations were detected unusually far to the west in Kansas, Oklahoma, and the Texas Panhandle, with the highest densities perhaps moving through San Angelo, Sonora, and even in far West Texas at Balmorhea--deftly skirting the Texas Hill Country this year.  The vagaries of weather patterns always leave me scratching my head when the Monarchs or the major hawk movements bypass us at this Refuge.  We can't take it personally--all these critters are just masters at "going with the flow", quite literally.  Some years we are the beneficiaries of these patterns (as we were with Swainson's Hawks in early October) and sometimes not; that's the fun and frustration of migration watching.

     The topic of how Monarchs accomplish the navigational feat of moving from the eastern and central U.S. to arrive at a small set of over-wintering targets in Mexico is worthy of greater essays than I have space for here.  This aspect has garnered much attention from inventive field and laboratory researchers.  I include a few of the more notable and recent titles in my reference list below.  But consider some of the major questions:  Even with some pretty good genetically-inherited skills, how would you figure out how to navigate to one tiny area in central Mexico that you've never visited before?  Landscape clues?  Magnetic compass?  Body clocks?  Wind/weather clues and cues?  The sun/moon/stars?  Head out to your garage and invent for yourself a "time-compensated sun compass" and you'll get a sense of what researchers have focused on in recent years.  The newest news on this topic involves the finding that the GPS system for Monarchs is apparently located in the antennae of the butterflies!

     At the Refuge, we have tagged about 50 Monarchs thus far this season on their southbound pathway.  The number we tag gyrates wildly from year to year (high: 234 tagged in 2001) based primarily on the aforesaid migration vagaries, but also on the available volunteer and staff time devoted to the task, and the grace and forehand skills of our would-be Monarch netters.  I believe Outdoor Recreation Specialist Rob Iski and new SCA volunteer Elizabeth Lesley are about tied for the lead in this season's tagging rodeo.

Refs and Further Reading

Websites:

Journey North, Monarch migration maps of Fall migration at:
    http://www.learner.org/jnorth/monarch/
     Click on the "Here's the latest news" link in the center of the page for great animated maps.

Library of Congress, Scientific Reference Services.  Science Reference Guides: The Migration of the Monarch Butterfly, online at:
     http://www.loc.gov/rr/scitech/SciRefGuides/butterfly.html
     This site has a good introductory bibliography of Monarch research.

Monarch Watch, Home page at:   http://monarchwatch.org/

University of Arizona, Honors Biology class page on Monarch migration:
     http://student.biology.arizona.edu/honors2002/group10/Monarchmigration.htm

Research Articles:

Lincoln P. Brower.  1995.  Understanding and misunderstanding the migration of the monarch butterfly (Nymphalidae) in North America.  J. Lepid. Soc. 49(4):304-385.

Lincoln P. Brower.  1996.  Monarch butterfly orientation: missing pieces of a magnificent puzzle.  J. Exper. Biol. 199:93-103.

William H. Calvert.  2001.  Monarch butterfly (Danaus plexippus L., Nymphalidae) Fall migration flight behavior and direction in relation to celestial and physiographic cues.  J. Lepid. Soc. 55(4):162-168.

Jason A. Etheredge, Sandra M. Perez, Orley R. Taylor, and Rudolf Jander.  1999.  Monarch butterflies (Danaus plexippus L.) use a magnetic compass for navigation.  Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 96(24):13845-13846.

Oren Froy, Anthony L. Gotter, Amy L. Casselman, and Steven M. Reppert.  2003.  Illuminating the circadian clock in Monarch butterfly migration.  Science 300:1303-1305.  Abstract at:
     http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/300/5623/1303

Christine Merlin, Robert J. Gregear, and Steven M. Reppert.  September 25, 2009.  Antennal circadian clocks coordinate sun compass orientation in migratory Monarch butterflies.  Science 325:1700-1704.

Steven Reppert, H. Zhu, and R. White.  2009.  Polarized light helps Monarch butterflies navigate.  Current Biology 14(2):155-158.

* * * * *
"Below The Line":

 
       In one migration narrative many years ago for the seasonal Texas column in American Birds, I elicited groans from my editors and readers when I penned the phrase, "Willets wandered widely..."  Hey, I call 'em like I see 'em!


"A mind is a terrible thing to waste, but sometimes it's a scary thing to use."

CWS                                

CWS_Street_sm.jpg
(Photo credit: Annie Sexton.
Wardrobe consultant: Mary Kay Sexton.
Luggage provided by Texas Dept. of Transportation.)

Comments

  • Thursday, November 05, 2009 3:23 PM | Anonymous member (Administrator)
    Don't you just love mother natures magical mystery tour?
    Link  •  Reply

 


Email- friends@friendsofbalcones.org

Mail- Friends of Balcones

  PO Box 4678

Lago Vista TX 78645

2018 © Friends of Balcones Canyonlands NWR

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software